| Rok | Conference Champions | Mistr | Vítěz trofeje Johna Gagliardiho |
|---|
| 1973 | | Wittenburg | — |
| 1974 | | Central College (IA) | — |
| 1975 | | Wittenburg | — |
| 1976 | | Třezalka (MN) | — |
| 1977 | | Widener |
| 1978 | | Baldwin Wallace | — |
| 1979 | | Ithaca | — |
| 1980 | | Dayton | — |
| 1981 | | Widener | — |
| 1982 | | Západní Gruzie | — |
| 1983 | | Augustana (IL) | — |
| 1984 | | Augustana (IL) | — |
| 1985 | | Augustana (IL) | — |
| 1986 | | Augustana (IL) | — |
| 1987 | | Wagner | — |
| 1988 | | Ithaca | — |
| 1989 | | Dayton | — |
| 1990 | | Allegheny | — |
| 1991 | | Ithaca | — |
| 1992 | | Wisconsin – La Crosse | — |
| 1993 | | Mount Union | Jim Ballard, Mount Union (QB) |
| 1994 | | Albion | Carey Bender, Coe (RB) |
| 1995 | | Wisconsin – La Crosse | Chris Palmer, Třezalka (MN) (WR) |
| 1996 | | Mount Union | Lon Erickson, Illinois Wesleyan (QB) |
| 1997 | | Mount Union | Bill Borchert, Mount Union (QB) |
| 1998 | | Mount Union | Scott Hvistendahl, Augsburg (WR, P) |
| 1999 | | Tichomořský luterán | Danny Ragsdale, Redlands (QB) |
| 2000 | - Americká jihozápadní konference - Hardin – Simmons
- Atlantická centrální fotbalová konference - Wesley
- Konference stého výročí - McDaniel
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin - Illinois Wesleyan, Millikin, a Wheaton (IL)
- Dixie meziuniverzitní fotbalová konference – Není jmenován žádný šampion
- Freedom Football Conference - Springfield
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference - Bluffton a Hannover
- Fotbalová konference Illini-Badger - Aurora
- Iowa meziuniverzitní atletická konference - Centrální (IA)
- Michigan meziuniverzitní atletická asociace - Naděje
- Středoatlantická konference - Widener
- Středozápadní konference - St. Norbert
- Meziuniverzitní atletická konference v Minnesotě - Bethel (MN)
- New England Football Conference - Nichols a Salve Regina (Modrá divize), State Bridgewater (Red Division)
- Hra mistrovství: Bridgewater State 27, Salve Regina 24
- Atletická konference New England Small College – Amherst, Colby, a Middlebury
- Atletická konference v New Jersey - Stát Montclair
- Atletická konference na severním pobřeží - Wittenberg
- Severozápadní konference - Linfield
- Atletická konference v Ohiu - Mount Union
- Atletická konference Old Dominion - Emory a Henry
- Atletická konference prezidentů - Washington a Jefferson
- Jižní Kalifornie meziuniverzitní atletická konference - Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference - DePauw, Sewanee, a Trojice (TX)
- Univerzitní atletická asociace - Chicago
- Athletic Conference Upper Midwest - Mount Senario
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference - Hobart, Rochester, a Union (NY)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference - Wisconsin – Stout
| Mount Union | Chad Johnson, Tichomořský luterán (QB) |
| 2001 | | Mount Union | Chuck Moore, Mount Union (RB) |
| 2002 | | Mount Union | Dan Pugh, Mount Union (RB) |
| 2003 | | Třezalka (MN) | Blake Elliott, Třezalka (MN) (WR, P, KR) |
| 2004 | | Linfield | Rocky Myers, Wesley (DE) (S) |
| 2005 | | Mount Union | Brett Elliott, Linfield (QB) |
| 2006 | | Mount Union | Josh Brehm, Alma (QB) |
| 2007 | | Wisconsin – Whitewater | Justin Beaver, Wisconsin – Whitewater (RB) |
| 2008 | | Mount Union | Greg Micheli, Mount Union (QB) |
| 2009 | | Wisconsin – Whitewater | Blaine Westemeyer, Augustana (IL) (OT) |
| 2010 | | Wisconsin – Whitewater | Eric Watt, Trine (QB) |
| 2011 | | Wisconsin – Whitewater | Michael Zweifel, Dubuque (WR) |
| 2012 | | Mount Union | Scottie Williams, Elmhurst (IL) (RB) |
| 2013 | - American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin – Baylor (13–1, 6–0)
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins (10–1, 9–0)
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – North Central (IL) (13–1, 7–0)
- Východní vysokoškolská fotbalová konference - Gallaudet (9–2, 6–1)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca (9–3, 6–1)
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin (8–4, 7–1) and Rose – Hulman (7–3, 7–1)
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg (9–3, 6–1)
- Liberty League – Hobart (10–1, 7–0)
- Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference – Stát Framingham (9–2, 8–0)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion (8–3, 6–0)
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming (7–3, 7–2) and Libanonské údolí (8–3, 7–2)
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert (8–3, 8–1)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Bethel (MN) (12–1, 8–0)
- New England Football Conference – Endicott (8–3, 7–0)
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Amherst (7–1, 7–1), Middlebury (7–1, 7–1), and Wesleyan (CT) (7–1, 7–1)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Jeřáb (9–3, 6–1) and Stát Brockport (8–3, 6–1)
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg (10–2, 9–0)
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Concordia (WI) (8–3, 6–0)
- Northwest Conference – Linfield (11–1, 6–0)
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union (14–1, 9–0)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden – Sydney (9–3, 6–1)
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Thomas More (9–1, 7–1) and Washington a Jefferson (8–3, 7–1)
- Jižní atletická asociace – Millsaps (9–1, 5–1) and Rhodos (8–2, 5–1)
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands (7–3, 7–0)
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Texas Lutheran (8–1, 3–0)
- University Athletic Association – Washington – Saint Louis (8–3, 3–0)
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – St. Scholastica (9–2, 9–0)
- USA South Athletic Conference – Metodik (8–2, 6–1) and Maryville (TN) (8–3, 6–1)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin – Whitewater (15–0, 7–0)
| Wisconsin – Whitewater | Kevin Burke, Mount Union (QB) |
| 2014 | - American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin – Baylor (9–0, 4–0)
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins (9–0, 8–0)
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Wheaton (IL) (9–0, 6–0)
- Východní vysokoškolská fotbalová konference - Husson (8–2, 7–0)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca (7–2, 6–2)
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin (7–0, 7–2)
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg (9–0, 6–0)
- Liberty League – Hobart (9–0, 6–0)
- Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference – Stát Framingham (10–1, 8–0)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian (8–3, 5–1)
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener (12–0, 9–0)
- Midwest Conference – Macalester (9–2, 5–0)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN) (10–2, 7–1)
- New England Football Conference – MIT (8–3, 7–0)
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Amherst (8–0, 8–0)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Stát Morrisville (9–2, 6–1), Stát Montclair (8–2, 6–1), and Jeřáb (7–4, 6–1)
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg (8–1, 8–0)
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Wisconsin Lutheran (7–3, 5–1)
- Northwest Conference – Linfield (10–1, 6–1)
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union (12–0, 9–0)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden – Sydney (7–4, 5–2)
- Atletická konference prezidentů - Washington a Jefferson (9–0, 7–0)
- Jižní atletická asociace - Centrum (10–1, 6–0)
- Jižní Kalifornie meziuniverzitní atletická konference - Chapman (7–1, 6–0)
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference - Texas Lutheran (8–1, 2–0)
- Univerzitní atletická asociace - Washington – Saint Louis (8–3, 3–0)
- Athletic Conference Upper Midwest - St. Scholastica (10–0, 9–0)
- Atletická konference USA - Christopher Newport (8–2, 6–1)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference - Wisconsin – Whitewater (9–0, 6–0)
| — | — |
